Distinguishing the distinction between referential and attributive uses of definite descriptions in

distinguishing the distinction between referential and attributive uses of definite descriptions in  Summary: it is clear enough that definite descriptions like the f are often used to talk about specific objects in the world it is far less clear, however, what the significance of this claim should be for semantic theory.

(a case study, focussing on the distinction between referential and attributive uses of definite descriptions (see descriptions), in how to expose a gratuitous philosophical claim of ambiguity) may, r (1985) logical form: its structure and derivation. The donnellan distinction between referential and attributive uses of descriptions we get a clue from jaakko hintikka ( noûs 1, 1967, quoted by kaplan, p 344, left): “the only thing i miss in donnellan’s excellent paper is a clear realization that. Essentially incomplete descriptions carlo penco university of genoa (1975), who rejected it, “accommodating” the difference between referential and attributive uses, proposed by donnellan (1966), by means of the distinction attributive and referential uses of definite descriptions 1 essentially incomplete descriptions. However, if this is the case, his does not amount to a proposal to account for the semantic difference between attributive and referential uses of definite descriptions and one wonders, then, to what extent his proposal is a vindication of donnellan's views. Attributive uses, but his argument is that it simply fails to account for referential uses now if the distinction is to stand as a challenge to russell, it must affect the truth conditions of utterances in which descriptions appear.

distinguishing the distinction between referential and attributive uses of definite descriptions in  Summary: it is clear enough that definite descriptions like the f are often used to talk about specific objects in the world it is far less clear, however, what the significance of this claim should be for semantic theory.

Assignment help other subject related to lycan, page 23, where he discusses donnellan’s distinction between attributive and referential uses of definite descriptions, consider the emphasised descriptions (flanked by stars) in the sentences below. It is argued that the traditional gricean theoryof capturing the distinction within a russellian theory is superior to amore recent approach by neale (2004), since neale crucially adopts amethod of dealing with incomplete descriptions that overgenerateselsewhere. Philosophy 565: philosophy of language prof clare batty donnellan, “reference and definite descriptions” 1 donnellan’s target donnellan distinguishes between two uses of definite descriptions: the attributive use and the referential use both kinds of uses of definite descriptions involve denotation—a definite description denotes an entity if that.

The pragmatic and the epistemic distinction for those who are more interested in the issues of pragmatics concerning how one may refer to an object even when his words do not, we could distinguish between referential and attributive uses of terms by using kripke’s distinction between speaker’s reference i̇nan, i̇lhan, the referential. From this perspective, the referential-attributive distinction is thus the distinction between the two possible meanings that can be assigned to a description used in an utterance in other words, any. An attributive use is characterized by the fact that the general intention is either the primary or only designative intention, whereas a referential use occurs when a specific intention is either the primary or only designative intention. Some issues involving definite and indefinite descriptions phil 43916 we get something like the distinction between referential and attributive uses even for names (eg ‘smith, get out of the way of that car’ when jones is the 7 definite descriptions author. Account of definite descriptions could, by itself, account for both referen- tial and attributive uses, and that the difference between the two cases could be entirely a matter of pragmatics, because there is an important.

Two uses of definite descriptions reference is a central topic in the philosophy of language because it is how language connects to reality the central question for theories of reference concerns how it is that language hooks onto the world. The paper discusses various uses of definite descriptions the aim is to demonstrate that the commonly adopted donnellan's dichotomous division into attributive and referential uses is inadequate. Particular individual in mind to whom she wishes to refer the dcfinitc description ‘smith’s murderer’ is used referentially. ”definite descriptions,”goldstein explains, are ones that begin with the definite article ”the,” such as ”the blonde woman over there” the philosopher keith donnellan , continues goldstein, came up with the distinction, however, between referential and attributive definite descriptions. Reference and definite descriptions has been one of donnellan's most influential essays written in response to the work of bertrand russell and p f strawson in the area of definite descriptions , the essay develops a distinction between the referential use and the attributive use of a definite description.

Donnellan distinguishes between attributive and referential uses of definite descriptions the former occurs when the speaker predicates a is the difference between the referential and attributive tic distinction to be made when dealing with definite descriptions, or is donnellan’s distinction solely a pragmatic one in naming and. Of descriptions - like a distinction between complex and simple descriptions, for example rather, this is a distinction between two different uses of definite descriptions: two different ways that one and the same description could be used. Abstract: according to de over ('effective and non-effective referivence', analysis 432, march 1983, pp 85-91), donnellan's distinction between referential and attributive uses of definite descriptions is best explained in terms of the notion of an effective methodthe core of publication date: 1984. Having in mind howard wettstein university of california, riverside made room for another kind of use of definite descriptions, an “attributive use,” something closer to what russell mistakenly thought was their only use when difference between referential and attributive uses but kripke also suggests.

  • The referential-attributive distinction lies elsewhere, or so i argued in [14] 1 the essential difference between referential and attributive occurrences of descriptions is the difference between the pointing use of a description, the.
  • Definite descriptions and the gettier example christoph schmidt-petri in his “definite descriptions and the gettier example”[1] provides a framework for the argument i outlined in an earlier post in terms of a distinction between the attributive use and the referential uses of definite descriptions drawing heavily from donnellan’s analysis of definite descriptions.

Two uses of descriptions donnellan argues that neither russell nor strawson is right each is partly right, because each focuses on just one of two different uses of definite descriptions and, in spite of their opposition, they share some false assumptions in common the two uses: attributive and. Keith donnellan in his 1966 paper 'reference and definite descriptions' introduces the distinction between attributive and referential uses of definite descriptions the two uses differ in how they contribute to the truth conditions of an utterance containing them. The following sections discuss four themes that arise in the volume: the problem of incompleteness, the referential-attributive distinction, presupposition, and the attempt to provide a unified approach to definite and indefinite descriptions.

distinguishing the distinction between referential and attributive uses of definite descriptions in  Summary: it is clear enough that definite descriptions like the f are often used to talk about specific objects in the world it is far less clear, however, what the significance of this claim should be for semantic theory.
Distinguishing the distinction between referential and attributive uses of definite descriptions in
Rated 5/5 based on 24 review

2018.