Re: voting should be made compulsory -deepa kaushik (05/04/14) voting should be made compulsory even if it is not a compulsion, it is the duty of every citizen of the country to cast their right to vote. The main argument against making voting compulsory is that the people that aren’t voting currently don’t care, and will just pick randomly and could make bad choices and undermine the votes of those that thought carefully. The position adopted in this essay is that voting in elections should not be compulsory australia is one of at least twenty countries which compel their citizens to vote in federal, state and most local government elections australia forced its compulsory voting (cv) laws on its citizens in.
Disadvantages of compulsory voting the most common argument against mandatory voting is individual freedom countries using compulsory voting force people to vote, but it can definitely be considered as a step against freedom of individuals. There are a range of arguments against compulsory voting, including that people shouldn't be forced to vote, that the system encourages ill-informed voting and will increase the number of donkey. Voting should be compulsory in the uk ballot papers could include an abstention box to properly register this message counting against the people who are actually voting on the basis of informed opinion in an extreme case, idiots could sway the result of an election. Compulsory voting is unconstitutional the only suit like that in recent memory is the one filed in the final days of the bush administration against the new black panther party for.
Given the strength of arguments on both sides, political consensus on compulsory voting is difficult to achieve but for voluntary voting proponents, shifting the status quo will also be difficult. Should voting be compulsory in australia compulsory voting was introduced in australia in 1924 after the voter turnout of those registered to vote in australia was as low as 47% since voting was made compulsory by the federal government, voter turnout has remained around 94-96. Voting, by contrast, is the process by which citizens delegate power to government therefore, compulsory voting would entail forcing large numbers of people to make an uninformed decision on a. The arguments against compulsory voting although supporters of a more engaged electorate accept that there are practical solutions to increase voter turnout, they argue that compulsory voting would be both fundamentally undemocratic and, crucially, ignores the reason why modern electorates often seem so disengaged by politics. Compulsory voting should be abolished no citizen should be essayswhen people talk about compulsory voting some say that yes it should be a law while others will say no it should be abolished, the really smart people might say that compulsory voting isn't a law its compulsory enrolment that is.
Compulsory voting has made the australian political system unresponsive if voting were made voluntary, it would shake up the political system parties and candidates would have to do more to convince people of the merits of their policies in order to get voters to the polls. Finally the compulsory voting makes no sense if a lower voter apathy is the only reason politicians should think about the reasons for the low turnout and not about the low turnout itself if the population is unsatisfied with the dominating political situation, the politicians should think about their policies at first and not about how to. Idea of compulsory voting after australia, singapore, and switzerland implemented compulsory voting and the turnout of voters grew, other democratic countries began wondering if the idea should be implemented globally. Compulsory voting - for and against published on state library of nsw ( ) compulsory voting - for and against  the main arguments for and. However, the arguments against compulsory voting cite this as the same reason that voting should be voluntary one of the most popular theories in the argument against compulsory voting is the lifeboat theory.
Arguments against compulsory voting the burden of proof argument because compulsory voting is compulsory, it is presumed unjust in the absence of a compelling justification a large number of purported arguments for compulsory voting fail there are no remaining plausible arguments that we know of. Arguments for mandatory voting arguments against mandatory voting voting is a right, not a duty people should have the option to refuse to participate in the system if they choose compulsory voting (international institute for democracy and electoral assistance):. Study of compulsory voting by elaborating the effects it is frequently held to have, and by systematically examining each of these effects against compara- tive evidence from around the world. In their fact sheet on voting, the australian electoral commission provides some arguments in favor and against compulsory voting arguments in favor of compulsory voting voting is a civic duty comparable to other duties citizens perform (eg taxation, compulsory education, or jury duty. Pte academic exam study guide pte academic writing pte essays pte academic essay voting should be compulsory or not sample essay pte academic essay voting should be compulsory or not sample essay this is the reason there are some people who are against compulsory voting.
Compulsory voting is ultimately not a big deal, fiona went on, given that belgium, greece and australia have the compulsory vote and in more recent cases the introduction of it has increased. If voting is a right, it can’t be a duty, and if it’s a duty, it can’t a right perhaps it’s neither i’ve assumed people have a right to vote, but let’s not be too hasty. The case against compulsory voting by padraic m c guinness in political matters, often the strongest case for a change in habitual arrangements is precisely that they are habitual and any change will, by shaking up the system, promote change for the better. Compulsory voting is within the scope of wikiproject australia, which aims to improve wikipedia's coverage of australia and australia-related topicsif you would like to participate, visit the project page start this article has been rated as start-class on the project's quality scale mid this article has been rated as mid-importance on the project's importance scale.
In this installment of our blog series on voter participation, we discuss the arguments for and against compulsory voting in most democracies being able to vote is a hard-won civic right however, in some countries voting is deemed a civic duty which must be carried out. Further, compulsory voting has been linked to reduced political corruption, potentially because it incentivises disillusioned voters, many of whom would otherwise stay home, to go to the polls and vote against improbity.